Thursday, November 29, 2007

Shaktar Victory

No matter how many times I've been there, seen it, lived through it, I just can’t bring myself to understand the magic that happens at Celtic Park.

About 65 minutes gone, there was just no way I could see Celtic scoring again, no way I could see them winning.

Far more intelligent and eloquent men that me, have failed to understand, never mind explain what it is about Celtic on these nights that make them the most special team in the world.

It’s not just the supporters, that would give you and I too high a place in it all. It’s Celtic. It’s the strip, the history, the players, the stadium, the songs, the hope, the belief (sometimes), the passion, the disappointment, the stage, the fans, the teams and players of days gone by. So many tangible’s make up the intangible beauty that is Celtic, that not only wins games like last night, but also reinforces the belief all around the world that Celtic are one of those special clubs. Where people are drawn to, and once here never can escape completely.

Celtic becomes a part of you, every bit as much as you become a part of Celtic:


Ninety-seven minutes to do it all again. To be deflated, to build yourself back up, to lose our way (and players), to bring ourselves back into it, to hate the opposition, to get hold of the match only to give away chances. All of this, to end where so many have ended before. Twelve months ago Nakamura did it, against Milan Scott McDonald did it. As Neil Lennon said "Yes I've seen this before, every time I come here, I don’t know why you're all surprised" It should have been, whose turn would it be tonight?

McDonald endeavoured and was directly involved in the first, with his sheer persistence causing the Shaktar defence enough concern to force the error giving the ball to the calm and impressive Jarosik. The buzzing from one defender to the next continued to cause them problems, and won a couple of the corners late in the game as we tried to keep the pressure on. But it wasn’t a day for McDonald or his less persistent partner Hesselink, to be the hero.

McGeady too, no lack of effort from the young Irishman, and like McDonald certainly played a supporting role in the story of the night. But his obvious talent led the Ukrainian side to double up on him, giving him a hell of a task to play his part as effectively as he has done. However, he worked away, and what the defence prevented him doing in terms of dribbling and taking them on, he certainly made up for in delivery. Two or three crosses giving opportunities that really should have broken Shaktar hearts, with Donati's 92 minute strike making up for Jarosiks far simpler first half chance.

Brown worked determined as ever and got about the pitch well, but there will be future European nights at Celtic Park where his name will be song at the final whistle. Much like Boruc, who one excellent save apart, had little chance to impact on proceedings in a match winning capacity.

Naylor and Kennedy, both had prologues giving them a script worthy of the last minute winner, however injury curtailed their games and both had to be replaced early on. Naylor having such a torrid start to the season, really looks to have got over it, and looks far more confident, what timing a hero's performance would have been for the willing fullback who had little time to do anything constructive before he went down in distress to be replaced my midfielder Donati in what had to be a tactical reshuffle. Even more concerning was the sight of the collapsed Kennedy on the Celtic Park turf, after his early mistake giving Brandao an easy chance for Shaktar to go one up, a goal would have been great for the big man, to ease the pain of the 3rd minute. Although that pales in significance to the worry that his first half substitution was a reoccurrence of the knee injury that kept him out for over two years. Hopefully it wont prove to be anything as serious as that, but indeed, Left him out of the race to be the man to bring Celtic back to touching distance of the last 16 of the Champions League.

McManus didn’t do too much wrong and a steady performance (albeit with mixed distribution) kept him away from the glory that he and McDonald enjoyed against Milan. After the cruel injury blow to Kennedy, Pressley took his place alongside McManus in the heart of the defence, and in truth gave one of his most assured performances in a Celtic shirt. Kept it simple, and gave the ball to those more gifted at the beautiful game than himself. In his first game in 7 months, Pressley even remained back at Corners thus ruling him out of any goal scoring opportunities, in a clear attempt to maintain a level of sharpness and energy until the final whistle.

If any player on the pitch was deserving of not only a victory, but also some personal glory, it would have been Paul Hartley. Will work tirelessly with all his experience in any position given, and showed that he will give his all for Celtic. Being shifted to left back would seem galling to most midfielders but Hartley got on with the task at hand and performed more that admirably. But an overlapping fullback he will never be, and was content to sit in, hold his position and let other vie for the glory.

It has been said before that Gary Caldwell is not good enough at Champions League level, however no-one can call into questions Gary's determination, effort, and most all off bottle. To his detrement Gary Caldwell will not hide, he will take the ball and he will try his best. Yes often that is not good enough, and I don’t think it will benefit anybody to turn Gary Caldwell into a good footballer, because it would be stretching the truth. But lets for once give him credit, credit that is deserved for anyone who works like he did last night, for the bottle he has, and for the help he has given us when he stands up to be counted. Spartak game, Boruc and Naylor almost crack under the pressure and go for each other, who splits them up Gary Caldwell, not our captain who is standing beside him. First penalty of the shootout to take us to the all important group stages, who steps up, a centre forward, Hesselink, no, a centre half, must be our captain then, no, Gary Caldwell. Against Milan his calm and controlled shot caused Dida more problems that Rab McHendry giving McDonald his goal. Last night, his efforts to get forward in the latter stages have to be applauded, as indeed does his slipped pass to Aiden on the wing leading to the goal.

But Gary will only ever be part of a team able to take Champions league points, if he has other players around him, good players, match winners. Last night, one such player, a good player indeed, was Jiri Jarosik. Not only did he put to bed the nonsense that he isn’t up for the fight, but he put in a goal and all round performance that was deserved of his man of the match award. Not the left midfielder that will hit the by-line, not only due to his natural foot being his right, but his game is far more on a calm, passing, possession play that on big nights is needed more than the plain effort and pace that fans sometimes think best. Jiri not only tackled, marked and covered his and any other man he could, he used the ball well, and along with his fantastic strike to draw level, got into two great positions from which he could have scored. What Jiri does particularly well, he refuses to be bullied into playing the rushed pass and has the presence of mind to build the move slowly without playing a pass blind just to force it forward, which in pressure situations is always a consideration.

However well Jarosik played, and how great a strike his goal was, there was one reason why Jiri Jarosik was not the name on the tip of 60,000 tongues leaving Celtic Park last night. That reason was Massimo Donati. With a basic overview, the Italian was purchased with Champions League performances in mind, so therefore last night was purpose built for him, and accordingly he delivered. Things, unfortunately haven’t been as simple as that for the likeable Italian, who was disappointed not to be named in the starting eleven for the second consecutive Champions League again. There was good reason why he was amongst the subs, Paul Hartley has been giving the type of performances, with grit, passion, composure, and stability that Massimo has struggled to show since the first couple of matches. Tonight he came on and tried to put that all right. It didn’t all work for him. But his effort was plain to see, and on the 47th minute of the second half, there was something else plain to see.

Massimo Donati had just become a part of Celtic and Celtic in turn had just become a part of him.

Tuesday, November 27, 2007

Post Aberdeen - looking to Wednesday...

Saturdays game was the best Celtic performance for a long time. With Boruc missing the game after pulling up with an injury in the warm up, it was good for Mark Brown to get a shut out. However having no saves to make, it wasn’t overly difficult for him, either way a good confidence booster (which may be important if he has to fill in on Wednesday again.)
With McGeady on his natural right hand side, with Brown one in from him, Aberdeen were given no chance by the sheer pace, power, and skill of the pair of young midfielders. Donati replaced Hartley(out with a virus) and was efficient enough, but with Jarosik and the two young players to his right dominating proceedings there wasn’t much need for Donati to pull out all the stops.
Naylor looking more and more the willing attack minded full back we witnessed last year, got forward all game, and indeed deserved to have turned in the chance he narrowly missed.
Kennedy, McManus, Caldwell and Brown will never have had such an easy afternoon, as the rest of the team kept Aberdeen on the back foot for such long spells it looked an effort for Aberdeen to get out of their own half. Without yet convincing that he is the talisman expected upon his arrival from Eindhoven, Hesselink not only got on the scoresheet but indeed couldn’t help but get involved with the fluency and speed of play when the midfield got up time and time again to support he and the ever impressive Scott McDonald.

Going into Wednesdays game, already without Nakamura and Wilson, hopefully the consistent pair of Artur Boruc and Paul Hartley will (as the club hope) recover in time for the match up with the Ukrainians.

Still concerened about the appearance of Caldwell in our backline in the Champions League, however a fitter Kennedy with an improved match fitness will help McManus to the level of performance he has shown beside David Weir. McManus has looked very much stretched agaisnt Donestk and Benfica so far this campaign, and will have to do better to ensure victory against the strikeforce that Donestk posses. Kennedy must be sharper alongside him, but hopefully playing the amount of minutes he has done recently will give him the boost our defence badly needs.

Naylor seems to get forward more with the experience of Jarosik or Hartley infront of him, with McGeady covering the ground infront of a rightback who isnt of capacity to support attacking moves the more likely choice, however to pack the midfield and give attacking options on the wings, I would have Brown wide right and MCGeady on the other side.
A big performance from Hesselink would be timely and take some pressure off McGeady and McDonald who so far this CL campaign have stood up to be counted more than most.

Boruc

Caldwell Kennedy McManus Naylor

Brown Jarosik Hartley/Donati McGeady

McDonald JVoH



Looking for impact from the bench of Zurawski in the second half as an important outlet for us also.
We really need to take 3 points from this one, so substitutes could be vital for us, with Riordan as an attacking left sided player might give McGeady's effectiveness a chance to play through the centre if we are still in search of goals late on in the game….

Monday, November 26, 2007

Celtic 3 - Aberdeen 0

From The Times

November 26, 2007

Celtic power to win thanks to Aiden McGeady’s masterclass

Celtic 3 Aberdeen 0

Phil Gordon at Celtic Park

When Scott Brown admits to being envious of someone else’s energy, it has to be a special talent. The eager Celtic midfield player is not one to stop in his tracks for anything, and certainly not to admire the view. However, even Brown feels second-best right now, compared to the raw power of Aiden McGeady.

Just seven days earlier, Brown left a few world champions gulping for oxygen as he took Scotland’s Euro 2008 fight to Italy. On Saturday, he put in one 90-yard run that tore Aberdeen apart and conjured up a pirouette that Zinedine Zidane would have been proud of. Yet, Brown still felt in awe of McGeady’s performance. The Ireland winger earned high praise from Gordon Strachan – “It was a flawless performance from Aiden,” the manager said – but the endorsement of Celtic’s £4.5 million summer signing from Hibernian probably counted more with McGeady. Kind words from the manager are important, but kudos from the dress-ing-room is much harder to earn.

Brown watched McGeady torment Aberdeen – finding the net with the same fierce accuracy from distance that he employed against Benfica four weeks ago – and he is hoping that his teammate is saving up of those goals when Shakhtar Donetsk come to Celtic Park on Champions League business on Wednesday. McGeady was sacrificed by Strachan when the two teams met in Ukraine on the opening night of group D, as the Celtic manager went for a 4-5-1 formation only to lose 2-0, but there is no chance of the 21-year-old being on the bench this time round.
“Aiden was frightening again,” Brown said. “For the last month, I don’t think anyone has been able to get close to Aiden. I hope that continues. Since I came to the club, his performances have been on a different level. His pace, his work-rate and his skill are incredible. He regularly runs 60 or 70 yards several times in a game, taking players on, but he still gets back to help out in defence. He has amazing energy.”

Jimmy Calderwood will also take his team into Europe this week, away to Atlético Madrid in the Uefa Cup on Thursday. However, the Aberdeen manager acknowledged that even in Spain he may not see a talent quite like McGeady’s. “We contributed to our own downfall but Celtic were magnificent and it was a wonderful performance by McGeady. Celtic’s energy and desire were terrific. Look at him and Scott Brown when they were 3-0 up, they were still hungry for the ball.”

During the week, McGeady can be spotted on Celtic’s training ground running with a harness round his waist as he drags a tyre, to improve his speed. On match days, it is opponents who seem laden down as they trail in his wake. McGeady symbolises Celtic’s progress in the Champions League this term: neither got out of the blocks in Donetsk but they are now well into their stride and Wednesday offers the chance to go second behind AC Milan.

“We were disappointing in Ukraine,” Brown said. “We lost two early goals and we tried to come back in the second half but it was not to be. This will be different. We are home, where we have a great record. The fans will be like a twelfth man for us and that will really help us. The performance against Aberdeen was one of the best I have seen. We had 11 players at their peak and we will need something like that against Shakhtar Donetsk. We have to win all our home games to have a chance of going through to the next stage in the Champions League. We’ve won the last two, against Milan and Benfica, and we badly want the victory from this one, too.”
Had it not been for Jamie Langfield, then Aberdeen would have been badly mauled in the manner that they so often were when Ebbe Skovdahl was manager a few years ago ago. This was three, going on seven. The goalkeeper produced a string of first half-saves to prevent Scott McDonald and Brown adding to the thirteenth-minute header from Jan Vennegoor of Hesselink and McGeady’s raking shot, on off the post. Jiri Jarosik also grazed the top of the bar with an audacious long-range effort.

Even though Langfield committed an error that allowed McDonald to pounce and secure his fourteenth goal of the campaign, after initially saving at the striker’s feet, the goalkeeper atoned for that in superb fashion in the 69th minute with a remarkable double save from McGeady and Vennegoor of Hesselink, as they rained down venomous efforts upon him.
Calderwood was deeply unhappy about Aberdeen’s display. Only Chris Maguire, the teenage substitute, was absolved from blame. “Chris showed great desire and no fear but I cannot say the same about more experienced members of the team,” the manager said. “They have been told a few home truths and if they don’t deliver, they will not play.”
Scott Severin, the captain, admitted that Aberdeen cannot afford to allow
Atlético Madrid the same latitude on Thursday. “It is a massive game for us but it will be a difficult one,” Severin said. “When we get to Spain, we want to cause them a few problems – we just did not do that to Celtic. It will be the biggest club game of my career, though I was on the bench when I was 18 and at Hearts and we played Real Mallorca.

“The manager was going to see Atlético play on Sunday night and he will work out a game-plan for us. We were on a good run until we went to Tynecastle to play Hearts before the international break and now we have conceded seven goals in two games. We did not do that last year. We were very hard to beat and we have got to get back to that standard.”

Celtic cruised past Aberdeen without the industry of Paul Hartley and the goalkeeping of Artur Boruc. The Scotland midfield player was suffering from a virus but should be ready to play on Wednesday but Boruc’s fitness is more of a concern, after picking up a toe infection while on international duty with Poland. Mark Brown was promoted from the bench when the problem became evident 30 minutes before kick-off. “There is something wrong with his toes, he can’t kick the ball properly,” Strachan said.

Thankfully for Strachan, there is nothing wrong with McGeady’s toes. He is quite simply, poetry in motion just now.

Celtic 3 Aberdeen 0

Scorers Celtic: Vennegoor of Hesselink 14, McGeady 27, McDonald 49

Celtic (4-4-2): M Brown 6 G Caldwell 8 S McManus 7 J Kennedy 8 L Naylor 8 A McGeady 9 S Brown 8 M Donati Y 6 J Jarosik 8 J Vennegoor 8 S McDonald 8 Substitutes C Killen (for McDonald, 77min), M Zurawski (for Vennegoor, 77), E Sno (for Donati, 82) Not used P Caddis, D Riordan, D O’Dea

Aberdeen (3-4-3): J Langfield 8 A Diamond 6 S Severin 5 L Mair 4 M Hart 5 B Nicholson 7 C Clark 4 R Byrne 5 J Smith 4 L Miller 4 S Aluko 7 Substitutes: C Maguire 6 (for Clark, 46min), J De Visscher (for Smith, 72), S Lovell (for Miller, 75) Not used D Soutar, R Foster, K Touzani, A Considine

Referee M McCurry
Attendance 58,000

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

Spanish Press

Printed in El Mundo, 8/11/2007PLEASE, DON'T EVER COME BACK AGAIN

Dear Rangers supporters- never come back to Barcelona again.And not because your players themselves aren’t a legitimate team.No, it’s not because of that- the Nou Camp frequently hosts teams who are lazy, boring, who only defend,who run and kick their opponents, and who shouldn’t be in elite competition.On top of this, Rangers merely defend, run at the oppositionand play dirty. Their defenders are butchers, their midfielders, heavy-footed; andtheir strikers just stand there like the furniture.

But even apart from the footballing aspect, the best thing would be for Rangers neverto return to Barcelona, because every time they do, they make a mess of the place. 35years ago, you (the Rangers supporters) destroyed the seats at the Nou Camp. Thistime we have enjoyed no less than 48 hours of brawls, provocation, rackets, fights andcommon drunk women throughout the whole city, which you have fouled howeveryou pleased.

Stay at home and vomit in your own living-room, urinate in your sitting-roomcorners, fight with your neighbours, the Celtic supporters (who deserve a prize just forputting up with you) and foul the streets of Glasgow instead. Don’t come back hereagain, because it is not a laughing matter. And, by extension, don’t play in theChampions’ League either. You are not at that level neither in a sporting nor humansense.

There are noisy groups of supporters who, although they drink vast amounts of beer,make friends at the same time. But you? Not you, because everywhere you go, youturn into a rubbish tip. You are undesirables. And so are those who fraudulently sell,or “rent out” their tickets. These people screw Barca over, because they trade theirseason tickets illegally. And in doing this they cause massive annoyance for othermembers of the club. A true Barcelona fan would not re-sell their ticket for the match.If you are not going to the match, give it to a family member, or you could even usethe 'Seient Lliure' service (an automated ticket service used by some Spanish clubsincluding Barcelona).

From now on, the responsibility lies with UEFA and the club itself to ensure who theticket is sold to. The best thing for all of us would be that you as a supporter, in amoment of lucidity, decide not to travel if you do not have tickets. As that is nevergoing to happen, those who sell the tickets illegally must be brought to justice. But thebest thing would be if we never had to play Rangers again.

Barca Failure for Rangers

Half the problem is the Scottish mentality on the playing field, which at least through playing and managing in England for so long, Gordon Strachan has partially escaped. However, its more than that, its the fine line between ambition/risk/good business. Seville couldnt have just bought Alves, Kanoute, Kersekov (Sp?!), Poulsten, Palop, and Luis Fabiano in one summer and think (a la Peter Risdale at Leeds) right if we do well then it willl pay for all their transfer fees and wages, if not - we'll go bust...
It's a building process. With Rangers and Smith - there isnt an overriding sense of future involved in anything thats happening. To me its even shown in simple things like... bBoyd is young, can score goals at any level, alright so he doesnt have a style thatat the minute suits playing one up front against the top teams int he world. In my eyes there are two options, one, dont play one upfront (particularly if your best striker isnt suited to it), or indeed two - you teach him and give him experience doing it so that he learns and as your team progresses he adds another string to his bow. Another part to that is, has he ever had any number of games playing the lone role or is it as simple as, he doesnt seem to work hard in a two so couldnt possibly do it himself?
Give barcalona the ball for 60-70% of the game against any team in the world and they will win - its sheer folly to even attempt it. The level of possession and pattern of paly was of such that if Rangers had gone 3 upfront then Barca couldnt even have had any more of the ball/game. If you play one upfront in a pitch that size agaisnt players of the Barca level, your two wide midfielders have to get up and support your forwards when you've got the ball - effectively they have to be the fittest, hardworking and bravest players on the park. Beasley doesnt have the bottle to go by SPL players so was never likely to do it at the camp nou. Had Novo and Naismith played the wider areas ten it might have given ranegrs a chance, an outlet even just to take the pressure off from time to time.
But both thos players are just auxillarily strikers, bar Burke (wherever he is these days) do Rangers have any natural width. Charlie Adam being told to get up and down the line, is just plain daft, if he does that for 30 mins he'l be leaving himself open to be run ragged for the rest of the game. I actually thought the occasions he drifted infield he looked rangers best and most composed player. In big games he plays with more bottle than Ferguson, who for huge spells I geniunely thought wasnt playing.
Rangers need to buy players, not just to win the next game, but to help them move to the next level, or even to sustain their position at this levelm or else, what the point of it all.
I dont buy into Barca on that form are unstoppable - Barca werent even on their game anything like to the level they can be. Its easy to say "aye thats a good score agaisnt a team like that", but its not, if you play like that you have to get a 0-0 or its just plain terrible. Its like you have allowed a team to beat you. As a celtic fan Ive seen it too many times also.
As we showed against Benfica, the best form of defence against teams of higher techinque is attack. But you have to pick the players and system to allow your attackers to attack. Two weeks ago we got done by benfica, they had all the pressure and almost all the chances, fast forward two weeks, we have far more chances, far more possesion. Whats the difference, we arent any better and they arent any worse, but we played to let our forwards cause them problems and take the pressure off our (shakey) defence. Playing at hom does give you a boost, but doesnt make bad players good and vice versa.
Thought McGregor, Hutton, and Adam all got pass marks, because they at least looked comfortable at that level.

Aiden Fantastic - Fans not so...

Aidens performance almost needs no further analysis than to say – Excellent.

Was absolutely disgusted to her audible booing as Evander came on last night

Greatest fans in the world – hardly

Disgrace....

The same people were pummiling Aiden not two months ago - they shouldnt even be allowed to watch him play...

I am shocked at the praise certian members of our defence are getting. There is a consensus that McManus had a good game. Celtic websites, and aparently Roy Aitken on STV were praising his performance. This has got to stop. How many goals, games, defensive partnership does he have to give away before we realise that he is still raw potential and still not that much more. He would be an asset with a steady, intelligent, classier centre half, but without one he suits the Celtic centre half bombscare role as well as anybody else. He gave away two or three goalscoring chances to them last night, had it been at the other end, McDonald would have a hattrick.

McGeady, Hartley, and McDonald were really good last night, we would have been lost without any one of them. If Killen was a bit more mobile he could have had a double.
Hesselink needs to get fit before he plays. Everyone who starts a game is in my eyes claiming to be fit enough so should be judged in the same terms as the rest of the team. Hesselink didn’t work hard, didn’t offer enough, and didn’t win highballs, whether or not this is down to fitness, heart, or ability, it really doesn’t matter. Im no Killen fan, but he did more, won more, and caused more problems than Hesselinks 80 minutes, in his ten minute cameo at the end...

McGeady had the raw materials and was confidence and phyical aspects holding him back
Sadly for Stephen and Gary, they are both confident 'footballers' who wont/cant improve much in terms of pace and strength....

Prince after King

"Scott McDonald is the king of kings...

Sadly, due to the ridiculous amounts of money in football and spiralling transfer fees a club legend now costs £50,000 more than one did a decade ago. Shameful."



He’s only 23 and still has a lot he can learn – but certainly has plenty of time to do that in. All the raw materials are there - we need to give him the platform to show us he can do it...
I was reading someone the other day talking about O'Neil and the day we signed Hartson, Sylla, and Guppy, saying basicly if ever it showed O'Neil was excellent at the 6 million range in the transfer market - but fails in the six figure signings was then.

Made me think that Gordon is the opposite. With the exception of Scott Brown, the 3 players we have spent the most money on are Gravesen, Jarosik, and Hesselink. None of them have been an unqualified success' for various reasons.

The likes of Naylor (bar a shocking 3 months that we have thankfully seen the back of), Artur Boruc, Scott McDonald, even Hatley and Nakamura cost less than 2 million each - All look like amazing value for money

Your Killen me Chris

Striker Chris Killen has become the latest Celtic player to complain about not being given enough first-team opportunities.


"I am always disappointed when I am not playing," he admitted. "I thought I had a good game at the weekend against Motherwell. You know in yourself whether you have had a good game or not. I think that is the same for every player.

http://www.theherald.co.uk/sport/headlines/display.var.1804163.0.0.php


Aye just cause Dianbobo and Derek feel hard done by - its not a queue for Diddies not starting eleven material to run to the press

Next we'll have Mark Brown telling us he should be ahead of Artur - infact thats not as riduculous as Killen moaning.

He started against Benfica and featured in several matches this season – which is far more than I thought. How many goals has he scored – One.

Complaints of 31/10/2007

O'Dea wasnt on the bench.

Infact no defenders were on the bench.

That is bad planning.

After watching Hesselink last night I would infer that he is a couple of weeks away from starting - I dont know how aparent this would have been in the training field to our coaches, but Im surprised after the level of his fitness that he showed enough to get a start.

We started okay mainly because we were doing well down the left with Aiden and Lee looking very sharp and lively, with Hartley ontop of everything in the centre. As soon as Lee came off, we lost Hartley from the middle of the park. Albeit he looked out of place at left back (and certainly not capable of Naylors 45 in that position, it was his void in the middle of the park that was our biggest loss. Clearly Sno was brought in to anchor and let Donati float forward, but along with leaving Hartley indeed, all at sea at leftback, the balance and position of our midfield handed them an oppurtunity to push 1 of there 5 midfielders on to drive (r) at our defense to support the hardworking Elliott.

I suppose its worth mentioning that Caldwell doesnt help proceedings, by giving away possession to their midfield with every clearance, but then, should we not just expect this now?

More worringly from my perspective, is, where does this leave us? Out of the CIS cup - yes, im sure we'll live. But who is available for Saturday and Wednesday, and infact more pressing, who will Gordon deem justifyable of a green and white jersey. Worrying enough that Gary Caldwell, Chris Killen, and Evander Sno were all looked upon good enough to knock Hearts out of the cup, are they they players Gordon feels are his best option. With Jarosik (and even O'Brien) an unused sub, Teddy Bjarnsson adding Tuesday's Rangers reserve game to his website man of the match pile, Riordan, Dianbobo, and Darren O'Dea all fit and raring to go - will Gordon stick with the players he knows didnt, and even cant perform against Hearts in the positions he played them.

Gordon, preseason and aftermatches (on the occasions he fancies a chat) makes alot of noise about knowing what is wrong and how to change it, and even how we should/could change system for each match. Thats all well and good, and surely we should seen signs of this before, lets for the moment forget about the past - Gordon has a duty to now change things. Players, formations, systems. Not for a minute do I think he or the players at his disposal are not capable of adapting, but there has to be a willingness to accept that what you have done and chosen in the past might not have been the best decision, and that you personally as manager made wrong decisions. The stubborness that keeps Gary Caldwell in my team, that keeps Stephen McManus as my captain, that kept Lee Naylor in my team at the start of the year (when he needed to be taken out as he couldnt have been playing worse), the stubbornress that wont play Jiri Jarosik in his chosen position, nor Riordan is a position he is proven in (whether its his favourite or not), this stubborness has to go, or else team 3 will go.

It will go from top of the league, it will go from Europe, but i'll tell you what won't go. Our dismal away form (champions league and defensively even domesticly).

PS - I heard the boo's coming out for young Evander last night - totally out of order. Yes he was poor, and indeed has had a noticeably poor start to the season, however at NO point last night did he hide. If he is put on the pitch, all you can ask is he does his best. If his best isnt good enough - its up to the manager not to put him on until his best is befitting of our starting lineup...

The Problem with Bobo

He has been treated appallingly because he is highly paid and Strachan fancied far poorer, cheaper players in his place - add Strachans inability to redress his views on players/situations when they dont work out = Problem

No McDonald?

I heard this question asked last night both before and after the game…

Is it me - or does this NOT answer the question - why was scott mcdonald on the bench?


The manager left striker Scott McDonald on the bench tonight, along with Shunsuke Nakamura, and revealed his reasons for his staring line-up.“It’s just a case that we have only two fit strikers at the club just now – Scott and Chris Killen,” he said. “Scott is in terrific form but he’s playing all the time and we’re asking a lot of him.“That’s why Chris played and he did alright. He should be happy with himself. We’ve had a few injuries and we don’t want to run them all into the ground. Our priority is to win the league.”


Why could Gordon not come out and say – we were going to defend for long periods and wanted the option of a high hopeful ball that Killen could win to take the pressure off our defence (and God they need it). But no, lets go for the smart arse answer…

Glorious Failure in Lisbon

Where was the glorious failure? I must have missed that in the midst of all those humps up the park (supposed defensive clearances) and benfica pressure...

Part of it is the players arent good enough - but its far more than that. Its a mentality, its believing that we can do something, its not having 4 or 5 midfielders sitting ontop of your defence cos they cant handle the pressure, its not bringing pressure on yourself, its taking pressure off, its making them defend, making them work, its keeping possession, 'it' in essence, is being Aiden McGeady.

We need to break out off the shackles of predisposed opinions on our players. We should hire a foreign manager in as a consultant for a week.

Kennedy once fitter could start at the back, cant last 90 minutes at this level at the moment - no use to us really. McManus is what he is - only useful at this level if playing along side a type of centre back we dont have on our books (an intelligent experienced classy one). Caldwell is a centre half with poor distribution and very prone to error, not a great resume for a right back. He was woeful last night, one of the main individuals who seemed intent on us not holding possession. I actually thought Naylor was far better last night that we have seen him at points this year, he took responsibility in possession, and particularly in the second half moved forward with the ball - but again, he could be part of a back four, but only with a capable other 3 helping him out. Relying on him isn’t fair (as he isn’t good enough for that) and is only ever going to bring more pressure.

Then looking at our midfield, or as they played last night, the player playing just in front of our back 4. No I don’t mean Paul Hartley, I mean all 5 of them. Whatever the reasoning for sitting so deep without possession is total suicide. To keep afloat in the champions league, you need not only to stand your ground defensively, but to ask questions of the opposition through your use of the ball. Yes this takes, confidence, ability, self belief, but is that too much to expect? I certainly don’t think so. Without doing so, what is the best we can expect? - I’ll tell you what - last night, exactly that. To play 90 mins without the ball, is to prolong the time till the goal(s). We need to play further up the park and play to them, an not only might we ease the pressure, but infact might create a few chances ourself. Hartley did okay, didnt use the ball particularly well, but then, who was available to take it from him, his jib was stopping them, and covering his defence, in that he sis a good job. Donati has to hold the ball, sometimes using the ball, isnt always passing it, using it can be holding it and control the tempo a bit. It wasnt motivation or workrate that Donati didnt show, it was positional discipline. Whether or not they were told to sit deep I dont know - but he attempted to play Hartleys role also.

Jarosik on the left? No thanks, the big man can play - but pushing him wide so he can support the strikers doesnt work. Aye Shaun and Aiden were at there most attacking in that role, but their games are based on dribbling, Jarosik's game is about winning the ball and controlling it then finding a pass and moving. He should have played centrally. He and Donati infront of Hartley should give enough protection and support to defence and midfield against a team of Benfica's ability. McGeady couldnt have done more but when he beat his man, majority of the time Killen wasn’t even in the box cause he had to work so hard just to be involved that in the later stages he was "running on treacle" to quote Provan. He put a decent shift in, and did fine for what he could. We left Brown to fill the canyon between midfield and forward. 60 yards for periods this was. How on earth can we build play with this glaring imperfection? We need to help ourselves as in the Champions League we'll just get punished.

Brown didn’t play badly as such - just in the wrong areas, there were so many Benfica players in the Gulf between Killen and the Midfield that hitting him with a pass from centre wasn’t much of an option, so he tried to use his energy and enthusiasm dribbling by players. I genuinely feel for us that would have been best served out wide given how deep or midfield was. McGeady on the left, Brown on the right would have served us better.

However I don’t think we have the players, know how, or system to play with one upfront against a team like Benfica, who lets face it, are hardly the cream of Europe. If you let most of the Champions League group teams onto you, they will do the same.

Above and beyond the shape and system-


Balde and O'Dea sitting on the bench - and we wonder why we cant defend.

Our best midfielder on the bench - we wonder why we cant pass or create chances

Our top scorer for the season was on the bench - we wonder why we don’t score

Hardly rocket science....


May I add (sadly) - That actually last night was an improvement in actual performance cos we sat deep 'well' for the majority of the game - Just don’t think we should (or have to) be even playing like that and don’t think it will serve is well to continue to do so in Europe.


Champions league is the pinnacle of club football - expect every team to "have to win", and yes we have to expect that teams like benfica will throw the kitchen sink at us. But does anybody honestly think the answer is sit back and watch them smash the enamel off Gary, John, Stephen, and Lee until the whole kitchen unit was forced over the goal line.
By no means do I think we should have been playing an overly attacking formation/team. But it’s the mentality that’s all wrong. That what its all about, personally I wouldn’t have gone with the 9-0-1 formation that we did, but even so, to play that way whilst being brave, strong, self believing, and with ability (see our number 46 last night) would certainly give you more of a chance of even getting the draw than booting the ball to Benfica's possession then sitting in and seeing how long it takes them to break us down, and see if we can manage to get lucky. We shouldn’t be looking to just get lucky, we should be looking to get good. If we get a bit of luck doing so, then that’s even better. In any way we lined up, we had to be prepared to play, to take responsibility for the game not being played 18 yards from Artur Boruc.
Yes Nakamura isn’t in great form, and I can even understand him being on the bench. I don’t understand not bringing him on, particularly when it was clear we were not passing the ball at all well. I certainly wouldn’t leave Naka out as we need him fit and in good form to bring to the 3 remaining CL games. I don’t think Naka "picks and chooses when he plays for us", personally I don’t think he has quite recovered his form since being injured. Perhaps a wee spell recuperating will bring him back in full fitness and full form.

Previous Posts....

Defensive worries going to Lisbon....
-------------------------------------

‘Steven Pressley, who has been a longer-term injury absentee, has also travelled and could play if required.
The experienced central defender, who has not played this season because of a back injury, could act as cover should McManus fail to recover.
Out-of-favour centre-half Bobo Balde checked in with Gordon Strachan's squad.’

I can confirm "It is not required Gordon"

If Balde didnt currently languish in our reserves - it would be a common perception that he would walk into our starting eleven. So he should do exactly that. Need to get Caldwell out of centre back role, id accept him playing right back - for 2 reasons, 1- we have little option/cover there, and 2 - he cant possibly cause the amount of upset to the team than he does in the centre


Rangers V Celtic team news....
------------------------------
Rangers keeper Allan McGregor and defender Alan Hutton are expected to recover for the Old Firm game at Ibrox. But manager Walter Smith has injury doubts over Brahim Hemdani, Jean-Claude Darcheville and DaMarcus Beasley. Celtic's Jan Vennegoor of Hesselink and Paul Hartley are doubtful with hamstring injuries, and Scott Brown is unlikely to feature.
Gary Caldwell is expected to shrug off a knee injury, while Maciej Zurawski is in the frame for a return.


Rangers: (from) McGregor, Hutton, Cuellar, Weir, Papac, Whittaker, Ferguson, Thomson, McCulloch, Naismith, Boyd, Carroll, Beasley, Adam, Darcheville, Gow, Cousin, Ehiogu, Broadfoot, Shinnie, Emslie, Lennon

Celtic: (from) Boruc, Kennedy, Caldwell, McManus, Naylor, McGeady, Nakamura, Donati, Jarosik, Killen, Scott Brown, McDonald, Mark Brown, Riordan, Zurawski, Sno, O'Dea, O'Brien



Michael's team

Boruc
Caldwell Kennedy McManus Naylor
Brown Donati Jarosik McGeady
Nakamura
McDonald

Subs O'Dea Brown Riordan Zurawski O'Brien Killen Sno

Naka playing as a number 10

It would be beautiful - The pace of Aiden and Brown hitting them down the flanks - supporting skippy (then magic from 70mins) with naka a free range of possesion, passing and through balls





Celtic 2 - Milan 1
--------------------
Caldwell was fantastic - as was Kennedy when he came on. And Doumbe was having a great game.

Jiri was great in my opinion, showed for the ball, took it in tight positions, and offered an added aerial threat for set pieces. He did however tire drastically in the second half.

Naylor playing with Hartley on LM on Saturday, then Jiri last night looked a far better proposition, and distribution was better.

He and Aiden do not link up well.

Dont think anyone foresaw Gordons tactical masterpiece that was playing skoosh right up off McDonald.

McGeady finished strongly, had he been so involved earlier on, the game could have been over by half time.

It was great to see Stephen score last night. Thought he had a reasonably good game - overshadowed by Gary's best game in a Celtic Shirt, and John's excellent cameo appearance.

Sky Sports announced Zurawski was starting proir to the game, then he wasnt even on the bench....








Celtic V Milan nerves……
---------------------------

Balde isnt even in the 20 man squad for tomorrow, I held a tiny tiny hope that he would partner McManus, in a Balde rises like a phoenix from the flames against all who overcome situation.

Only O'Dea, Jarosik, and Zurawski left in my romantic hero like fairytale for tomorrow...


I would not start killen

I would like to see Jarosik and Zurawski at somepoint in the game

If Naka is anything less than 80% I do not want to start him



I cant decide how I would play it. Without Hesselink, at home, Id consider the old chelsea 433/451 Id love to see a front 6....

Brown Donati Nakamura
McGeady Riordan
McDonald

But I dont see us going for that, or Riordan being strong enough to start. if we go one up front, We should be looking at McDonald for 60 mins and Majiec for 30mins as itl be a hard shift for the wee man. Hartley is on form, physically strong, and works his backside off, could we do without that?
I’m fearful of Naylor and Caldwell (if he is played at CB). But then Kennedy looks like he could be doing with being a bit fitter. Is doumbe ready for it? Is he strong/experienced enough? On the flip side, could he give us that threat from fullback that didier did to great effect. If we go quite tight in central areas, a raiding fullback (aslong as they can get back also) could work really well.
Too many questions…..


Definite starters
Boruc (THG)
McManus
Donati
Brown
McGeady
McDonald


Perhaps

Boruc

Caldwell Kennedy McManus Doumbe

brown donati hartley

McGeady Naka
McDonald


Subs

brown
Naylor
Zurawski
Sno
O'Dea
Riordan
Jarosik
killen






Celtic 3 - Dundee Utd 0 ....
------------------------------
McGeady on that form is in the top 5 players in british football. He was unstoppable, and he had McDonald (the just someone to put the ball in the bloody net that we were crying out for last season) to finish off his good work.

Hartely still looking good, as is brown. Was the least influential Donati has been in the spl so far. I have been dying to see big Killen get a decent run out, after his 58 minutes doing so, I dont need to see him much more. Not saying he wont ever be usefull, just dont think he will ever seriously challenge our strikers for a starting game if they are fit.

Id go Zurawski McDonald up top on Wednesday.

Naylor did better, Doumbe albeit looks shakey from time to time, stops the cross in every time - which is promising. Gary and Stephen were not challenged at all during Saturday, that said, I do worry for Gary at centre back in europe. Id even rather see him at right back as he looks less vulnerable there.


As For Milan - I expect them to be formidable.

I expect Aiden to be even better

I dont expect to win. I hope we win 2-1





League Cup in Dundee....
----------------------------
Hardly a disaster as we won the game but I am starting to seriously worry that Gordon sees the faults in his team that others do, and left unaddressed it will cost us .

I dont read any newpaper, and spend very little time on CQN these days. Im just going on performances to starting lineup and strachan interviews (pre and post matches) - and i geniunely doesnt think he sees the problems.

I've called for Balde well before people started complaining about McManus/Caldwell partnership. What signals are we sending out to Lee Naylor, no matter how poorly you play you will not be dropped. Conversely with McGeady, no matter how well you play, you might be dropped.

When Gordon took over, we had ability in midfield, and goals up front, what we needed was a defence. He has never dealt with it sufficiently, and I am shocked that only now people are starting to pick up on it...
I dont have any qualms that we will win the league, and I dont think Gordon Strachan is completely inept as a manager, just think (like many managers) his stubborness to admit/see mistakes prevents him from bettering himself (and in turn Celtic)

Riordan didnt step up to the plate at all - Had Aiden been playing, he would have ran riot. Evander did reasonably well, but I would have thought a Donati/Sno partnership would have allowed Mo to bomb on, but they seemed a bit confused who was to sit and who was to support the front men. Hesselink looked the out of sorts way he has lately (so much so, I do wonder if that is him in sorts). Caldwell at right back was always going to be limited.

I thought Naylor was better than he has been of late. Kennedy did okay, I do wonder what we CAN defend against, we always hear, "we struggle with small nippy players", but Dundee pitched up against us, with several huge players, and our defence won very few headers. Boruc's shot stopping was exemplary, but was not protected by our defence on cross balls, allowing three, 6 foot plus, dundee players to go right ontop of him every time.

Dundee - were excellent. There young players look good technically (Swankie and McDonald in particular) but also their sheer physical threat gave Celtic problems. Swankie (silky winger) had 3 excellent freekicks, one hitting the post, and Boruc saving the other two, the big polish lump upfront, won everything and knocked it down to midfielders timing their runs brilliantly, and wingers drifting in to support when needed. Kevin McDonald (the Dundee goalscorer, big powerfull ball player) patrolled the middle of the park with grit and a swagger that last night Scott Brown would have wished for, can totally see why Celtic bid for him last season.

O'Brien should have been on to give a bit of width, Killen deserves a start in current climate, and we HAVE to see Darren and/or Dianbobo in the starting eleven now .




Donestk Disaster...
-------------------
I completely understand why Aiden didnt start, but if I was picking the team, he would have been the second name down on the team sheet (Artur - how long will he stay at Celtic when the gulf between his ability and ours becomes more and more aparent - Boruc, being first)

There was a long list of things that were wrong with us last night. To an extent, I certainly buy into the "I do not think we are in a position to expect good results away from home" theory, however I think we deserve, infact - we are entitled to expect we are not out of the game after 10 minutes.

I was asked the question - . Would you feel any better if we had lost the two goals in the last ten minutes?

Much better as it goes.

With progression (long term I mean) in mind, its not the scoreline that is always the most important, its the manner of the scoreline, and the positives which can be taken for it.
Its hard to judge positives playing against a team who are playing in a game they have already won

If McManus controlled the ball adequately then the ball from Brown wouldnt have been a poor ball.

However Brown was lost out there - Id have brought him off earlier on and got McGeady on. Even before half time - to send out the message - here, this games not finished yet.

Didnt see a particular amount of heads not going down. Mo's did for a spell, however when he got over it, he showed again, and looked far better. Hartley cant be blamed for his wide left performance, but I wouldnt have thought he would have been as poor. Did ok once moved infield. Naka's passing looked like he had been watching Naylor. McDonald was my one praiseworthy outfield player. Endevoured, ran, showed, and got a few shots off.

There tight three in midfield's main weakness is allowing fullbacks to push onto them, so Naylor and Wilson saw more of the ball then anyone else in our team, and were given space. To have done better, we needed fullbacks more complete than the level we have. And on the night, neither even defended well. Would have even rather seen doumbe play given their tactics (which theyve used for the past year), so we could have used our fullbacks as a beacon for us to move forward as a unit and get Mo and Brown involved further up the pitch.

Killen looked sharp and movement was good, but playing as little football as he has this season, he was never going to change anything. I would have brought magic on earlier.

Darren has to be brought in for a few spl games to get him back involved, in europe, his mobility and distribution is NEEDED in our defence.